Books HOME LOCAL L.A. Now Politics Crime Education O.C. Westside Neighborhoods Environment Obituaries Findlocal U.S. Politics Now Top of the Ticket Science & Environment Obituaries Religion WORLD Afghanistan & Pakistan Africa Asia Europe Iran Iraq Latin America Mexico Under Siege Middle East Business Money & Co. Technology Personal Finance Small Business Company Town Jobs Real Estate Autos SPORTS Lakers Clippers Dodgers Angels NFL Ducks/Kings USC UCLA Soccer High Schools Scores/Stats ENTERTAINMENT Movies Television Music Celebrity Arts & Culture Company Town Calendar The Envelope Findlocal Health Booster Shots Fitness & Nutrition Medicine Behavior Healthcare Reform Hospitals Living Home Food Image Books Findlocal Brand X Magazine Your Scene Cars Travel California Hawaii Mexico Las Vegas Europe Travel & Deal Blog Destinations Opinion Editorials Op-Ed Letters Opinion L.A. Deals Save: Deals Go: Travel Eat: Food Wear: Apparel Live: Everyday Needs Play: Electronics Drive More Mobile Site Subscribe / Manage Account Print Ads Place an Ad LAT Store Jobs Cars Real Estate Rentals More Classifieds 
Weekly Ad#inTheNews {min-height:20px;} Advanced Search Advanced Search X include all of these words: include any of these words: include this exact phrase: exclude: Select a date range this week past 30 days past 3 months past year Create a custom date range From: To: Jacket CopyBooks, authors and all things bookish« Previous |Jacket Copy Home| Next»Goodbye, Oxford comma? Hello, Shatner comma!June 30, 2011 | 12:46pm
Rumors of the death of the Oxford comma have been greatly exaggerated.
The Oxford comma, thought by some to be an annoying punctuation foible, appears in a list of multiple items before the "and." Here's how the Oxford comma looks in a sentence: "Scotty transported Spock, Kirk, McCoy, Sulu, and a redshirt down to the planet's surface."
The Twitterverse erupted Wednesday that the Oxford comma had been dropped by none other than the Oxford University Press. The AtlanticWire reports:
Yesterday, Mediabistro's GalleyCat ran a post that made it seem like Oxford University Press was dropping the use of its eponymous comma, also known as the serial comma. The story took off and became a Twitter meme so big that by today it had its own Associated Press story. But unfortunately for GalleyCat (or maybe fortunately, because it seems to be getting them a lot of clicks), it wasn't exactly true. The instruction to do away with the comma, which follows the last word in a series, appeared not in the OUP style guide, but rather the guide issued for the University of Oxford Public Affairs Directorate...
What's good about a Twitter kerfuffle is that while it might be full of outrage and disappointment -- I myself retweeted the sad but inaccurate news -- it is also full of people who can see the bright side. Even the bright side of a punctuation's ostensible demise. One such, writer Everett Maroon, was quoted by the Atlantic: "Professor friend o mine is against losing the Oxford comma, but wishes his students would lose the Shatner comma. You, know, what, he means."
The Shatner comma! That, is, you, know, a really, fantastic, idea.
See, the problem people have with the Oxford comma is that it puts a pause where some think one doesn't belong. The idea is that "I went to the market to get triple sec, limes and tequila" is better, or more modern, than "I went to the market to get triple sec, limes, and tequila." And the Shatner comma? It, does, nothing, but, put, pauses, where, they, do, not, belong.
As anyone who's ever struggled with punctuating a long list knows, the Oxford comma can come in really handy. One example of why it's needed was circulated on Twitter, and here's an amended version of its loss gone wrong: "Among those interviewed were Mr. Smith's two ex-wives, Kris Kristofferson and Robert Duvall" -- turning Kristofferson and Duvall into the ex-wives of Mr. Smith.
The Oxford comma, also known as the serial comma because of its appearance in a series, is alive and well, even at Oxford University Press. We know it is, because the press itself linked to its Oxford comma guidelines -- in the hotbed of the punctuation debate on Twitter.
-- Carolyn Kellogg
RELATED:
Pottermore: It's an interactive reading experience. But it's not online yet.
Jacket Copy on the Road: The Jack Kerouac house in Orlando
A literary journal editor reveals the secrets of getting published
Photo: William Shatner as the, expressive, James T. Kirk in the original "Star Trek" television series. Credit: File
Twitter: @latimesbooksFacebook: latimesbooksMore in: online, writing.entry {border-bottom:0px; padding-bottom:0px;}#sponsored1 {margin-bottom:15px;}
PreviousNext 
More from Jacket CopyComments () | Archives (0) var countNum = 0;if (countNum == 0) {jQuery("#archiveShow").css({'display' : 'none', 'visibility' : 'hidden'});jQuery("#commentsDivider").css({'display' : 'none', 'visibility' : 'hidden'});};jQuery('#fbShow').click(function () {jQuery('#commentsArchive').css({'display' : 'none', 'visibility' : 'hidden'});jQuery('#fbComments').css({'display' : 'block', 'visibility' : 'visible'}); });jQuery('#archiveShow').click(function () {jQuery('#fbComments').css({'display' : 'none', 'visibility' : 'hidden'});jQuery('#commentsArchive').css({'display' : 'block', 'visibility' : 'visible'}); });/*jQuery('#fbShow').css('color' , 'white');jQuery('#archiveShow').css('color' , '#666666');*/
L.A. Times on Facebook
AdvertisementIn Case You Missed It...The LatestMost ViewedMost Emailed Explore Bestsellers Lists
Browse: Dates Titles Authors Search: Find a title Find an author
Recent NewsTurkish publisher in trouble over William S. Burroughs book | July 5, 2011, 3:58 pm »Janet Reitman's 'Inside Scientology' is well-researched and compelling | July 5, 2011, 11:28 am »George R.R. Martin calls for 'head on a spike' of 'A Dance with Dragons' leaker | July 5, 2011, 8:22 am »French novelist plans to file attempted-rape charges against Dominique Strauss-Kahn | July 4, 2011, 6:16 pm »John Green makes like 'Go the F-- to Sleep' and hits Amazon's bestseller list | July 1, 2011, 4:10 pm »
Categoriesacademiaadvertisingamazonanimalsappsarchitectureartaudioaudiobooksauthorsbeabenjamin buttonbestsellersbiographybook clubsbook festivalsbook reviewsbook trailersbooksbookstoresbusinesscaliforniacarolyn kelloggcelebritycharitychildren's literatureclassical literaturecomicscoverscraftscrimecriticismcurrent affairsdavid ulindeborah netburndenis johnsondenverdesigndoing gooddonationsdrmdrugsearthquakesebookseconomicseducationenergyenvironmentereadersessayseventsfantasyfashionfictionfilmfood and drinkgamesgardeninggooglegraphic novelhealthhistorical nonfictionhistoryholidayhorrorhow tohumorindiainternationalinterviewjon thurberkindlela eventsla times bestsellersla times book prizela times festival of booksla times reviewlanguagelawlibraryliesl bradnerliteraturelos angelesmagazinesmargaret wapplermediamemoirmiddle eastmoney walksmusicmysterynew reviewnextnick owcharnobody movenonfictionnovelnovellaoff the shelfonlineparentingphilosophyphoto booksplayspoetrypoliticspomo monthpop cultureprizespublishingradioreadingreading liferearviewrelationshipsreligionrock your books offromanceschool readingsciencescience fictionself-helpsexshelvesshoppingshort storysportssummer readingsusan carpentersusan salter reynoldssxswitechnologytelevisionthe reading lifetheaterthrillertranslationtravelurbanismvideovideo gamesweb extraweb/techweblogswordswritingya
ArchivesJuly 2011June 2011May 2011April 2011March 2011February 2011January 2011December 2010November 2010October 2010September 2010August 2010July 2010June 2010May 2010April 2010March 2010February 2010January 2010December 2009November 2009October 2009September 2009August 2009July 2009June 2009May 2009April 2009March 2009February 2009January 2009December 2008November 2008October 2008September 2008August 2008July 2008June 2008May 2008April 2008March 2008February 2008January 2008December 2007November 2007October 2007September 2007August 2007July 2007June 2007May 2007
Stay connected:
About the ReportersCarolyn Kellogg
Orli Low
Nick Owchar
Susan Salter Reynolds
David L. Ulin
More from The Times24 FramesAfterwordAll The RageAwards TrackerBabylon & BeyondBig PictureBooster ShotsBrand XCompany TownCulture MonsterDaily DishDodgers BlogFabulous ForumFrameworkGreenspaceHero ComplexHomicide ReportJacket CopyL.A. at HomeL.A. NowL.A. Times on TumblrL.A. UnleashedLa PlazaLakersMinistry of GossipMoney & Co.Opinion L.A.PolitiCalPolitics NowPop & HissReaders' RepresentativeShow TrackerTechnologyTop of the TicketTravel News & DealsVarsity Times Insider
Corrections Horoscopes Media Kit About Us Contact Us Site Map
Coastline Pilot | Daily Pilot |Huntington Beach Independent | Valley Sun | Burbank Leader | News Press |KTLA |Hoy | Brand X | LA, Los Angeles Times Magazine | ZAP2itBaltimore Sun |Chicago Tribune |Daily Press |Hartford Courant |LA Times |Orlando Sentinel |Sun Sentinel |The Morning Call
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Los Angeles Times, 202 West 1st Street, Los Angeles, California, 90012 | Copyright 2011
A Tribune Web siteView the original article here
This post was made using the Auto Blogging Software from WebMagnates.org This line will not appear when posts are made after activating the software to full version.
No comments:
Post a Comment